SAP’s S/4HANA License Schemes Are Confusing Customers
SAP’s native-cloud play through S/4HANA dangled the hopes of a simplified license structure to SAP customers. This would have been a pivot from what is arguably the most complex software licensing scheme in the software industry. Instead, SAP customers now must navigate four distinct license models, each tied to a separate deployment model (perpetual license, subscription via HANA Enterprise Cloud [HEC], S/4HANA Cloud Single Tenant, or S/4HANA Public Cloud).
Source: Enterprise Resource Planning at SoftwareReviews
S/4HANA – The Choice is Yours
The table below summarizes each of S/4HANA’s license types along with the key commercial factors associated with each license type. Future notes will drill down deeper into each deployment model and license type to identify the key considerations for each option.
Of critical import for would-be S/4HANA customers is that the deployment model has significant impacts on both the license types available as well as the ability to customize the environment to meet specific business requirements.
For example, the perpetual license is most often tethered to an on-premises deployment. The perpetual license provides maximum flexibility for the pricing model, which can be a traditional SAP named user license plus a flat fee for S/4 platform access or the newer S/4HANA user license. The price model decision will hinge on whether the client is exercising a full contract conversion or a product-only conversion to S/4. Second, perpetual license holders can opt for either the runtime or full-use HANA database. Finally, clients purchasing perpetual licenses can choose to have their S/4HANA environment deployed on-premises or hosted in a private cloud or HEC environment.
|
License Term |
Functionality |
S/4 Enterprise – Price Model |
HANA (DB) |
HEC, IaaS, Managed Services |
|
|
Perpetual License |
Perpetual |
On-Premises |
SAP Named User + Flat Fee OR Per S/4HANA User |
Full Use OR Runtime |
Optional (fee-based for hosting or managed services) |
|
HANA Enterprise Cloud (HEC) – Subscription |
Subscription |
Same as On-Premises |
SAP Named User + Flat Fee OR Per S/4HANA User |
Full Use OR Runtime |
Customizable – included in subscription |
|
S/4HANA Cloud – Single-Tenant Edition |
Subscription – SaaS Model |
Same as On-Premises |
Full-User Equivalent (FUE) *New |
Runtime – included in subscription |
Standard based on FUE count – included in subscription |
|
S/4HANA – Public Cloud |
Subscription – SaaS Model |
Cloud (Multitenant) |
Full-User Equivalent (FUE) *New |
Runtime – included in subscription |
Standard based on FUE count – included in subscription |
Whichever path is selected to migrate to S/4HANA, the best time to negotiate the deepest discounts with SAP is now. With less than 10% of SAP customers live on any portion of S/4HANA, coupled with the just-announced pushback of the 2025 end-of-support date for Business Suite 7, SAP is likely to offer exceptional pricing and terms.
Recommendations
- Plan purchases of perpetual licenses with detailed price data. Obtain granular, detailed line-item pricing from SAP, including list price vs. discount price, to calculate minimum discount levels required to meet the ERP budget constraints. Where possible for legacy customers, explore product conversion and extension policies that preserve legacy contract terms and investments.
- SAP HEC proposals must be unbundled. HEC comes with a single price, which makes discerning the various component pricing impossible. Force SAP to provide pricing broken down by licensing, hosting, and service segments. Evaluate each individually to better target negotiations.
- Carefully map users to the best license type for S/4HANA Cloud. New license types (Advanced, Core, and Self-Service) are assigned to S/4HANA Cloud users. These license types are converted via a user ratio to realize the FUE count minimums. Apply analytical rigor to assess the financial risks and leverage automated software access management solutions and processes to accurately class users.
Bottom Line
Prospective SAP S/4HANA customers must plan carefully when deciding on the license model and deployment model upon which their environment will operate. This decision will determine the overall limits around system customization, HANA database choice, and single vs. multitenant cloud. These decisions cannot be rolled back later – this is a one-way street.
Want to Know More?
Explore the Secrets of SAP Digital Access Licensing
Explore the Secrets of SAP Software Contracts to Optimize Spend and Reduce Compliance Risk
SAP Presents a Generational Opportunity to Re-Negotiate Your ERP Contracts
SAP S/4HANA and HANA Licensing Series – Part I: The Forced “Upgrade”
SAP S/4HANA and HANA Licensing Series – Part II: HANA DB Hype?
SAP S/4HANA and HANA Licensing Series – Part III: Migrating to S/4HANA Will Cost More
SAP Is Getting Sued by Teradata for Taking Away Your Choice – A Game of Monopoly?